Exactly. People who would have gotten offended are probably those who WISH it wasn’t true. Unfortunately we don’t dictate what is true, we simply observe it.
Its like how do we differentiate East Asian from white? When the skin is white and hair is straight.
How do we differentiate west African from East African when they skin tone may be the same and some people from both regions with type 4 hair
How do we differentiate Southeast Asian from East African when skin and hair texture can also be the same (wavy or loose curly hair)
How do we differentiate blasians from mulatos (we still use this term in mainland Europe).
Black people come in an array, yes. But your features will match your skin naturally.
At my lightest I get mistaken for half black half Arab, half Southeast Asian, half North African or fully East African, or maybe my granddaddy white, this was even though my skin was lighter than a white/black biracial friend of mine and our hair texture is the same. Our phenotypes were different so it was clear I was not white/black biracial.
Having broad nose and dark pink lips is perfectly beautiful, I have a relatively “broad” nose too, no shame to it - at the same time it doesn’t match NC30 at all and I’m trying to look as natural as possible so there’s limits.
Again, black people have that bleach with very obviously stereotypical black phenotype (West African features) can be (maybe) mistaken for mixed by some but our black people will know lol.
mmm exactly
for me taking offense to pointing out certain features as typically black means that the person deep down view them as ugly or inferior
and in my opinion no feature in particular makes someone unattractive or attractive
what makes someone beautiful is how harmonious and symmetric their face is and how the face looks with all the features put together
so having certain eye color , or skin tone doesn't automatically make someone attractive or unattractive the same for having kinky hair or big nose
for me phenotype is just a foundation, a lot of variations can happen based on it which is why it doesn't make sense to crown one phenotype as attractive or unattractive
it varies from person to person
most people are average and a minority are below average or above it and an even smaller minority is the extreme of the spectrum: extremely attractive or extremely unattractive (according to society standard)
my point is no feature or phenotype should be seen as good or bad
me personally that's one of the reasons I was so conservative with my skin lightening at first
my initial shade is lupita and even back than I had some people not believing I was 100% black and questioning my ethnicity and background
in general I have typical black features but the combo of a small head/face and very small eyes throws people off
when I'm at a very low weight my face looks even smaller and my little niece even accuses me of "looking Chinese "
so my problem with lightening my skin is that I didn't want to stop looking fully black
I wanted to look black but with a lighter skin tone not mixed with anything but I realize with my features it's a bit inevitable
it's ironic because among my ethnicity in africa my features aren't that rare, so no one questions or doubt when I say I'm 100% black
another thing I notice is that back home I' considered pretty but in a normal meh type of way
people don't get out of their way to compliment me and they don't think I'm anything special
in fact I was made fun of for having a small head
but when I'm in Europe or America the perception is completely diff, I'm considered a lot more attractive and it isn't only with me a lot of women from my home country in africa that are considered "gorgeous" internationally , inside the country they are just seen as okaysh
it goes to show that there is no point of attributing any value to any particular feature because it's all very relative and subjective based on the value a particular society places on it