L'Oreal Glam shine does work and it not sticky at all. Maybeline new super gloss is brilliant or you can try the new MAC gloss in Tube (although it got brilliant shine, MAC gloss doesn't really last that well)
Try Clinique's Long Last Glosswear. At times, it feels sticky but the lasting power is incredible. If you just tap your lips very lightly after applying the gloss, 70% of the tackiness of the gloss feels lessened.
Or you may like to try Max factor lip Tints. just finish with a touch of clear gloss and the colour lasts on the lips for hours and hours.
I like Avon's Smooth Minerals Lipgloss. Even after a few hours, if I end up using a chapstick style protector (and I keep them everywhere!!), I still have good color. Most others go by the wayside by then.
I like the Buxom lipglosses. Also, I've been using the Smashbox lip stains that have a stain on one end of the applicator and a lip balm to make lips glossy on the other end. Since it's a stain it lasts a long time.
Highend brands like MAC,Nars and makeupforever...you get more bang for your buck!
even when it wears off, it leaves a beautiful stain on your lips.
You should also look into OCC liptars, they last long and a little goes a long way. They have a huge selection of colors.