Those are some good cleansing products. I was just suggesting the Nioxin bcuz its good at cleansing w/ out stripping the hair of natural oils like a lot of clarifying shampoos. It also promotes a clean healthy scalp area to promote the growth of the hair. And, it's made for thinning hair or normal hair. You just have to check out their stuff. It's great for thinning edges. With Nioxin, you CAN use it everyday if you wash your hair everyday.
NIOXIN? Research Laboratories: Nioxin - Professional products for thinning hair go check out their website and see for yourself or you could go ask your stylist about it or a licensed professional that deals with maintaining and promoting healthy hair growth bcuz, let's face it. ***no offense*** Not all people who do hair are good at it. But clarifying shampoos only cleanse the hair and don't really do much else as far as thinning hair. Nioxin is a product I can truly recommend if you have thinning hair.